Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Edward Dodson's avatar

Joseph and Mary Fels were also dedicated Zionists. However, they realized that attempting to carve out a Jewish state in the Middle East would engage the Jewish people in centuries of war with the very tribal Arab peoples. Their thought was to negotiate the purchase of territory somewhere in the western hemisphere not already occupied by a large number of people.

Expand full comment
David Harold Chester's avatar

The idea of the JNF bought land in Israel being kept for eternity by the national government was never properly withheld after statehood. This was mostly due to the first socialist governments under Ben Gurion, which behaved to support the apparent need for giving the kibbutzim sites that was theirs, and not merely leasing the land to them as originally proposed. (Incidentally my parents gave public concerts to help collect money for this kind of land purchase from local sources, well before the State was established in 1948.)

In my opinion this land distribution was a disaster and it was fortified by the creation of the separate organization of The Israel Lands Authority, which had the power to sell useful sites of land to private and commercial organizations. Gradually the JNF were forced to exchange their now valuable sites for less well developed places, on which many could be forested and not used for urban developments. In 1960 Ben Gurion got a law passed which regarded the total value of a developed site as one thing, not requiring the evaluation for sale of real estate in its more rightful two kinds of separate values, land and buildings separately.

By the means of the most useful land now being sold, less taxation was required on an already overburdened population, all of which had to pull itself up without causing such offense, were the government to rely only on producer/consumer based taxation sources.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts